CPE Week | Join us for our second annual CPE Feast, November 30 to December 3 | Register here about this announcement

Customers
Login
Optro's logo

November 20, 2026 • 17 min read

Risk as decision support: Defining uncertainty, mandate, and strategic tradeoffs

martin stevens

Martin W. Stevens, Audit Director, Gjensidige Forsikring ASA

Risk management is receiving greater executive attention as leaders are reminded that uncertainty is the operating environment. Geopolitics, interest rates, supply chains, cyber risk, and shifting customer expectations rarely arrive one at a time. Instead, they compound, creating second-order effects that are harder to anticipate than the headline event.

I have spent years working inside enterprise risk management, both as an internal auditor and through the risk management network within the Institute of Internal Auditors in Norway. One pattern shows up repeatedly: Organizations say they want risk management to improve decision-making, yet the actual work focuses elsewhere. Many organizations update their risk registers on schedule. They maintain taxonomies, complete annual assessments, and produce the required reports. But what they often end up with is a set of documents that may or may not reflect the risks that will shape performance over the next twelve months.

The goal should be to make risk management useful for making decisions, helping organizations make clearer calls under uncertainty rather than producing documentation after the fact.

The administrative trap

I remember when the first COSO framework documents were published — I read the ISO standard on risk management closely. The frameworks were sound, but organizations have often misinterpreted them in practice, making enterprise risk management more of an administrative exercise than a source of operational value.

A typical risk management cycle produces a risk register, a set of annual assessments, heat maps scored on likelihood and impact, and a board report. All of that work happens on a fixed schedule. But conditions don't wait for the next assessment cycle. By the time the board reads the summary, the competitive landscape or regulatory environment may have already moved past what the documents describe.

Operational risk management and internal control are necessary. But when ERM stops there, organizations end up with detailed documentation of the risks that historically account for a smaller share of losses, while the risks that drive the largest share of value destruction get the least formal attention.

Start with the definition

How an organization defines “risk” shapes behavior across the function in ways that are easy to overlook. If risk means only a possible negative future development, teams tend to minimize it, hide it, or push it to someone else. If risk means uncertainty about future outcomes, covering both upside and downside, it becomes a practical input to decisions about growth, investment, and market positioning.

The ISO definition aligns with this second framing: risk is the effect of uncertainty on objectives. That definition is useful because it accommodates opportunity without encouraging recklessness. It shifts conversations with internal audit, information security, and the risk function from “Prove you are safe” to “Show me what could change our outcomes, and what we are doing about it.”

When I have polled audiences of risk and audit professionals on how they define risk, the responses are divided almost evenly among those who define risk as purely negative, those who see it as covering positive and negative outcomes, and those who use "risk" for downside and "opportunity" for upside. That lack of alignment is not academic. It shows up in how risk work is scoped, how it is reported, and whether leadership treats it as a constraint or a planning tool.

In the guidelines we produced within the IIA Norway risk management network, we settled on a clear position: risk is the management of uncertainty with respect to the future. ERM looks at the totality of the enterprise, not risks in silos. Ultimately, this approach helps the organization make better decisions.

The strategic risk imbalance

Multiple surveys conducted over time have analyzed what causes significant losses in company share value, and they consistently point to the same pattern: Strategic risk is the leading driver. The ERM Report 2025, a study of 669 listed companies, found that strategic failures were the single largest cause of share-price crises at 41% of cases, more than double the 19% attributed to preventable internal shortcomings. A survey of Norwegian trading companies produced a similar pattern with a figure of 63%. The exact percentages vary by methodology and sample, but the direction is consistent: Strategic risk accounts for a disproportionate share of value destruction relative to the attention it receives.

Now compare those figures with how most organizations allocate risk management attention. In NC State’s 2025 State of Risk Oversight report, a survey of 273 organizations, IT and compliance risks receive the most formal consideration in enterprise risk processes (66% and 58% of respondents, respectively), while emerging strategic and market risks rank last at 43%. In other words, most organizations are better at governing familiar risks than surfacing the ones that could reshape the business. Only 22% of organizations say their risk management process “mostly” or “extensively” engages management in thinking about risks five to 10 years out. The category of risk most likely to destroy share value receives the least structured attention.

This imbalance persists partly because "strategic risk" often gets reduced to "strategy implementation risk" in practice. Strategy implementation risk asks whether the organization is executing the chosen plan effectively. Strategic risk asks whether the strategy itself makes sense given current conditions, constraints, and plausible futures.

As an internal auditor, I frequently see the same implementation problem: The plan looks solid on paper, yet the organization continues operating the way it always has, and the strategy never gets rolled out. But the higher-value question for risk management is whether the assumptions behind the strategy still hold, and whether the trade-offs embedded in it have been stated explicitly. That requires involvement earlier in the process, when options are being shaped, and assumptions are being set, not only when delivery is underway.

Mandate, independence, and the right skills

When I ask risk managers what they are there to do, the most common answer is some variation of "we help the organization manage risks." That answer is correct, but it does not explain the unique value added by the function. A stronger mandate states why the function exists, which decisions it is meant to improve, what outputs it owns, and how success will be measured. Without that specificity, risk management tends to slide into coordination and administration.

Independence does not mean being adversarial toward management. It means having the authority to speak plainly, surface uncomfortable findings, and provide a view of the organization that is not shaped by day-to-day operational pressures.

When risk leaders have consistent, credible access to the CEO and the board, including periodic opportunities to meet with the board without executive management present, discussions become more candid. This is not about catching management in a misstep. It gives board members space to ask the questions they might otherwise hold back, and it gives the risk function a channel to present its findings without filtering. In my conversations with chief risk officers, many have told me they would value unfiltered access. The board members with that access report that it improves conversations.

The people dimension is often the hidden constraint. A colleague of mine who served as chief risk officer at a major energy company described the challenge of expanding his team: HR did not know what profile to recruit for. Is a risk manager a controller type? An analyst? A business advisor? The answer is that a risk leader today needs business fluency to advise on strategy, analytical strength to quantify impact in financial terms, and communication skills to translate complexity into decisions that leadership can act on. Operational risk management experience is a strong foundation, but the value appears when risk management moves beyond reporting what happened and starts helping leaders compare options and understand exposure before decisions are finalized.

From single-point estimates to quantified ranges

A practical change that makes a measurable difference is moving organizations from deterministic to probabilistic thinking. Boards and executive teams are accustomed to receiving single-point outcomes: payback in six years, delivery in four years, cost at a fixed number. Under pressure, those numbers improve, and everyone feels better, even though the underlying uncertainty has not changed.

I recall a situation where a board was evaluating an acquisition. The CFO presented a business case with a six-year payback. The board felt that was too long and asked for the numbers to be revisited. At the next meeting, the payback had become four years. The board approved. No one asked the question that mattered: What probability was attached to the original estimate, and what probability applies to the revised one?

The same pattern shows up in major projects, especially technology initiatives. Experienced practitioners will privately acknowledge that timelines and budgets routinely double. When this pattern is well-known, as it is in most organizations, the uncertainty should be reflected in the business case from the start as a quantified range. Splitting a project into milestones and modeling each with realistic distributions, using techniques like Monte Carlo simulation, produces ranges that reflect actual uncertainty rather than relying on a single optimistic estimate. When a board receives a range with explicit probabilities, the conversation shifts from "Will we hit the number?" to "What confidence level are we comfortable with, and what would change the odds?"

Risk matrices have a role in basic prioritization, but they are limited tools for strategic decision-making. They evaluate risks in isolation, hide the combined effect of multiple risks, and compress uncertainty into a single point on a grid. As one prominent risk management thinker has observed, you probably would not use a risk matrix to make a meaningful personal decision, and if you did, you would recognize it as little more than a rough first pass.

Reporting that supports decisions

Risk reporting often consumes significant effort yet produces limited insight. The difference shows up in how reports are structured.

A pie chart showing the distribution of loss incidents by category tells a reader where losses occurred. It might show that business disruption accounts for the largest share, followed by execution and delivery issues. That is a snapshot. A bar chart showing the same categories over time tells a reader what is changing, what is getting worse, and what is improving. The second format invites the questions that actually matter: Why has this category increased? What is driving it? What should we do about it?

The same principle applies at the strategic level. Backward-looking reports and annual snapshots can be outdated before they reach the board. In a world where conditions shift quarter to quarter, reporting needs to surface trends, connect risk developments to strategic objectives, and reach decision-makers in a cadence that allows them to act before commitments are locked in. A four-year forecast that presents a single line without any indication of the spread around it is difficult to take seriously when the uncertainty compounds with each additional year.

Ownership and the duty of care

A recurring source of confusion in risk management is the question of who owns risk. The answer is direct: Line management owns risk. Executives and operational leaders make the choices and bear the consequences. The risk management function does not sit in the driver's seat on business decisions.

But I am skeptical of risk management departments that respond to this by saying, "We are not responsible for risk management. It is the organization's responsibility; we just process information." Risk management carries a duty of care. That means challenging whether assessments are meaningful, testing whether major risks and controls have been identified, and providing assurance that the organization is not overlooking something significant. Professional integrity requires the function to do more than pass along what it has been told.

The direction of travel

Risk management needs to move in the direction of continuous monitoring, using real-time indicators where they add value, and building a culture where surfacing problems early is treated as professionalism rather than failure. When a loss event occurs, the question should be what the organization can learn and how it improves going forward, not who is at fault.

That value comes from helping leaders make better decisions with clearer information about uncertainty, exposure, and tradeoffs. It requires a defined mandate, real independence, and the analytical depth to quantify what matters.

The test of whether risk management is effective is whether it changes decisions. If the function produces reports and assessments that no one references when evaluating an acquisition, approving a project budget, or setting strategic direction, it is underdelivering. The most useful question any risk leader can ask after a major organizational decision is: "What changed because of risk input?" When the answer is specific and traceable, the function is working. When no one can point to what changed, there is work to do.

About the authors

martin stevens

Martin Stevens, FCA, CIA, is a senior leader in internal audit and governance with a career dedicated to strengthening risk management practices across the financial and insurance sectors.

You may also like to read

A woman holds a laptop while two children peer over her shoulders to look at the screen with her
Risk

Building a mature enterprise risk management plan

LEARN MORE
woman sitting and smiling at laptop screen
Risk

Cyber risk quantification framework: A practical guide

LEARN MORE
featured image
Risk

Best enterprise risk management software in 2026: 10 compared

LEARN MORE

Discover why industry leaders choose Optro

SCHEDULE A DEMO
upward trending chart
confident business professional